On what basis does james michael cavanaugh (document 15.5) claim to be in a better position than benjamin butler to judge the best way to deal with indians? what assumptions about indians and their culture underlie the policy of assimilation advocated by reformers such as helen hunt jackson (document 15.6)? how does thomas nast's illustration (document 15.7) highlight the contrasting arguments made by congressman cavanaugh (document 15.5) and helen hunt jackson (document 15.6)? what options did indians have when confronted with white determination to eradicate their culture? what choice does zitkala-ša (document 15.8) make? why? how does chief joseph's experience (document 15.9) reflect the fundamental contradiction of federal policy toward indians?

Answers

Answer 1
Final answer:

Helen Hunt Jackson documented injustices against Native Americans yet supported assimilation, a policy reflective of her time that is now viewed critically. Her work paradoxically combined a reform agenda with American expansionism, embodying the contradictions within federal policy towards indigenous people.

Explanation:

Helen Hunt Jackson and the Policy of Assimilation.​​​​​Helen Hunt Jackson, an advocate for Native American rights, is perhaps best known for her critical examination of U.S. policy towards Native Americans, particularly in her 1881 book A Century of Dishonor. Jackson documented the federal government's repeated failure to uphold treaties with Native American tribes, condemning the forcible seizure of indigenous lands. Despite her efforts to highlight these injustices, Jackson supported the prevalent idea of assimilation, which was the process by which Native Americans would adopt the cultural beliefs and norms of the dominant Anglo-American society. This reflected the common, albeit ethnocentric view of the time, that assimilation was synonymous with progress and a sort of humane alternative to the outright eradication of Native peoples.

Jackson viewed the reservation system as a vehicle that prolonged what she deemed 'uncivilized' traditions among Native peoples, which she believed obstructed their ability to assimilate into Anglo culture. Ironically, while Jackson decried the history of broken treaties and injustices, she was, in fact, a product of her own time, holding views that may today be perceived as limited and emblematic of a colonial mindset. Her advocacy for assimilation aligned with the land hunger of the dominating Anglo majority, effectively merging a 'reformist' agenda with the expansionist desires of American settlers.

The contradiction within the federal policy towards Native Americans lies in its pretense of civilizing efforts while systematically eroding native sovereignty and identity. Historical figures such as Jackson played a complex role, oscillating between mercy and cultural obliteration under the guise of progress and civilization. It is a complexity that continues to be unpacked and criticized in modern discourse on cultural preservation and historical justice.


Related Questions

The attack on Pearl Harbor occurred on a Sunday morning. True or False

Answers

 True, the attack on Pearl Harbor occurred on December 7, 1941, which is a Sunday Morning

hope this helps

The maastricht treaty, which established the european central bank, states that the government of the countries in the european monetary union

Answers

ERUPEAN BANK STATES THE GOVERMENTS LAW

Which of the following would most likely be found in Byzantine art?
A.
portraits of ordinary people
B.
marble statues of Roman gods
C.
woven tapestries of emperors
D.
mosaics of Christian religious figures

Answers

mosaics of Christian religious figures

It should be noted that the type of art that would likely be found in Byzantine art is D:mosaics of Christian religious figures.

Byzantine art serves as type of art that encompass a sophistication style with spirituality of expression.

It is a kind of art containing architecture, paintings as well as other visual arts , which wad been produced in the Byzantine Empire.

We can conclude that Byzantine art is fond of mosaics of Christian religious figures and other spiritual kinds.

Learn more about Byzantine art on;

https://brainly.com/question/1800370

1. The process by which the Constitution was approved by the states is known as

A. levying.
B. impeachment.
C. vetoing.
D. ratification.

Answers

D! Hope this helped!

What's the main idea in the ninth amendment

Answers

That all rights not listed in the constitution belong to the people and not the government. Basically saying that the rights of the people are not limited to just the rights listed in the constitution.
This amendment was suppose to allay federalists that by guaranteeing specific rights to the Constitution  so that they would not protect other unspecified rights.

What delayed the inauguration of the new government under the U.S. Constitution?

Answers

Congress could not agree on where the temporary capital should be.

Bad weather kept many members of the new government away.

Congress lacked a quorum, so it could not finish counting votes for President.


Congress lacked a quorum, so it could not finish counting the votes for President.


Explain how human technology and social development fostered the rapid movement of people throughout the globe during the latter phases of the Paleolithic Era (c. 60,000 to 12,000 BCE).

Answers

The possession of fire and tools with which to make clothing and shelters made it possible for different human species to extend the range of their habitation far beyond the current savanna where they live.In the late phase of the palaeolithic Era, Humans also have developed several advancements in tools that is made by stone.
This tools include weapons such as arrow, axe, and spear, which is much more effective than wood based weapon when used in hunting and more durable if it brought for long distance travel.

describe how attitubes toward equality evolved during the colonial era

Answers

SLAVERY was a central institution in American society during the late-18th century, and was accepted as normal and applauded as a positive thing by many white Americans. However, this broad acceptance of slavery (which was never agreed to by black Americans) began to be challenged in the Revolutionary Era. The challenge came from several sources, partly from Revolutionary ideals, partly from a new evangelical religious commitment that stressed the equality of all Christians, and partly from a decline in the profitability of TOBACCO in the most significant slave region of Virginia and adjoining states.

Name the explorers who did not always sail under the flag of their native land. Under what nations’ flags did these explorers sail?

Answers

Columbus,an Italian sailor, was funded by Spain. Another Italian, John Cabot, sailed under the English flag. Vespucci, an Italian explorer, sailed with a Spanish expedition. Magellan, a Portuguese sea captain, was funded by Spain. Hudson, an English captain, sailed on different expeditions under the Dutch and the English flags.

The explorers who did not always sail under the flag of their native land include Christopher Columbus, Vasco da Gama, and Ferdinand Magellan.

Christopher Columbus, an Italian explorer, is well-known for his voyages under the Spanish flag. His most famous expeditions were sponsored by Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand of Spain. Columbus's voyages led to the widespread knowledge of the American continents in Europe and are considered the beginning of the European exploration and colonization of the Americas.

 Vasco da Gama, a Portuguese explorer, is famous for being the first European to reach India by sea, a voyage that linked Europe and Asia for the first time by an ocean route, connecting the Atlantic and the Indian oceans. This historic voyage was, of course, undertaken under the Portuguese flag.

Ferdinand Magellan, a Portuguese explorer, is known for leading the Spanish expedition to the East Indies from 1519 to 1522, which ultimately resulted in the first circumnavigation of the Earth. Although Magellan was Portuguese, he undertook this voyage under the Spanish flag after falling out of favor with the Portuguese king. Magellan's fleet was financed by the Spanish crown, and his flagship was named the Trinidad.

These explorers' decisions to sail under foreign flags were often driven by the political and economic climates of their times, as they sought the patronage of monarchs who were willing to fund their ambitious voyages of discovery.

How did the first Great Awakening affect attitudes towards religion in the colonies in the 1700's

Answers

Before the Great Awakening, the attitude towards religion was that it was a necessary part of society, and people would view religion as a chore. Additionally, religion was often united with politics.

During the Great Awakening, people began to see religion emotionally and spiritually. Sermons became more "revival-like". There began to be greater toleration of different peoples, and it changed the way many practiced their religion.

The biggest significance in the Colonies was how it prepared the Colonists for the Declaration of Independence and the following events. They began to see religion as a personal power, instead of one owned by the state. (Like the Church of England.) They began to be more independent and more self-confident in all types of freedoms.

Answer:

it increased tolerance of different religions

Explanation:

i took the test and got it right :)

A period of heavy migration greatly increases world population. True Or False

Answers

It doesn't increase or decrease, it just moves the population from one place to the other.
False , if true than sorry most facts lead up to no 

How does the first sentence of the Preamble express the principle representative democracy

Answers

The U.S. Constitution Preamble sets out the goals of the government and provides an introduction to the Constitution and the State. It expresses the principle of representative democracy, meaning that the people hold the power exercised through elected representatives, and lays out the promotion of general welfare, justice, tranquility, defense and liberty to all citizens. The statement "We the people..." effectively conveys this central idea.

Someone who wants the credentials of skilled training but in less time than a four year degree should consider what

Answers

that person should consider hands-on training and work in a firm that allows a person to do hands-on, get paid, and learn at the same time. The person would give his time to learn and work

hope this helps

how would you describe Celtic society and explain the Celts' lack of state building?

Answers

The Celts were not an unified state but rather a group of numerous tribes that often didn't even speak the same language. They were found all around Europe and were mostly Warriors who build their societies around kinship. They were good farmers and mostly were common people. They didn't have a strong unified state because they lived day in day out, women would give birth to children and men would work on the land and occasionally fight against invaders. There was no spirit of a great Celtic nation.

Which of the following did John Muir encourage in his articles and books?
A. The creation of a federal bank
B. The use of nuclear energy
C. The preservation of wilderness
D. The breakup of monopolies

Answers

The correct answer is C.

John Muir ( also known as John of the Mountains  and Father of the National Parks ), was a Scottish-American naturalist, book author, environmental philosopher and an avid advocate for the preservation of wilderness in The United States.

In his books and essays he described his adventures in nature, especially in the Sierra Nevada. With his dedicated work he helped to preserve many wilderness areas such as the Yosemite Valley, the Sequoia National Park and many others.

Muir was also the co-founder of the Sierra Club which is a prominent conservation organization.

Muir's life work has been inspiration to many politicians, congressmen and leaders to take action to preserve large nature areas.

Answer:

C. The preservation of wilderness is the correct answer.

Explanation:

John Muir was  environmental philosopher and naturalist. He is known as the father of national parks as he is one of the first persons to advocate for the preservation of  the wilderness in USA. He wrote many essays, books and letters to describe the adventures he had in nature. His efforts helped in preservation of the Yosemite Valley and Sequoia national part. He was well known for being political spokesman, ecological thinker. He was of Scottish- American ancestry and his birthday was celebrated for the first time on April 21,2013.

Historians label an event as a turning point when it

Answers

Answer:

c

Explanation:

Marks the beginning of a distinct historical period.

Read the statement. Achieving independence requires sacrifice and determination. This statement is the The Crisis, Number IV’s minor premise. conclusion. major premise. body.

Answers

The correct answer is C), major premise.  

Thomas Paine wrote the "American Crisis", a collection of articles written during the American Revolutionary War.  

Paine wrote “Common Sense” written in 1776, a famous pamphlet supporting the Independence from England. The essays he wrote refers to his support for a government just for America. History says that General Washington found the first essay so inspiring that he ordered that it be read to the army before going to battle.

Crisis number IV –dated September 12, 1777- says that the men who expect to get of freedom, first, must go through the sacrifice to supporting it.


Answer:

major premise

Explanation:

The crisis Number IV, published in London in 1775, tried to speak to commmon people in a political language that they could understand, this was the most read publication in the States prior to common sense, and its major premise was the bloodbath and unmoral thing that would be engage a civil war agaisnt the declaration of independence of the United States.

Why was the continental congress leery of our country becoming a democracy

Answers

Great Britain would be losing a great amount of money if the US becomes an independent country. The US is Great Britain's source of raw materials and commodities. Many products are made in the US and are then exported to England. An example would be tobacco and tea. They will lose control of all the plantations that they have created in the US.

how were the cities the ancient chinese built different from the cities the people of the indus river valley in india built?

Answers

The people of the Indus Valley Civilization did not built massive monuments, like their contemporaries, nor they built rich among their dead in golden tombs, there where no mummies, no emperors, and no violent wars or bloddy battles in there territory. hoped it helped men      

Which country became involved in the Korean War to stop the spread of communism?

Answers

America and her allies will be your answer

mainly America, but there were French, British, Italian, etc country troops that were in there (includes Zimbwabwae and Australia and New Zealand) The US and SK troops made up the most, the others just sent what they could

hope this helps
Final answer:

The United States became involved in the Korean War to stop the spread of communism, fearing a potential domino effect in Asia. They led a UN military force to assist South Korea when North Korea, backed by the Soviet Union and China, invaded with the intent to reunify the peninsula under communist rule.

Explanation:

The country that became involved in the Korean War to stop the spread of communism was the United States. As part of their foreign policy strategy known as containment, the United States aimed at preventing the expansion of communism during the era of the Cold War. When North Korea, supported by the Soviet Union and China, invaded South Korea aiming to reunify the peninsula under communist rule, the United States, viewing this as an attempt to spread communism, stepped in.

Unwilling to lose another Asian country to the influence of communism, President Truman approached the United Nations, which condemned North Korea's actions and called for the assistance of member nations in defense of South Korea. The United States, fearing a domino effect which could lead to the spread of communism in Asia, responded by leading a UN military force to aid South Korea. Therefore, the major role of the United States in the Korean War was driven by their intent to halt any progression of communism.

Learn more about United States in the Korean War
https://brainly.com/question/4292602

#SPJ12

name the four types of vegetation found in Africa

Answers

1. Forest  2. Grassland 3. Tundra 4. Desert 

how did islamic expansion most likely affect trade in arabia

Answers

I think Arabia merchants would conduct trade over wider areas.  

The correct answer is C) Arabian merchants could conduct trade over wider areas.

Islamic expansion most likely affected trade in Arabia in that Arabian merchants could conduct trade over wider areas.

The expansion of Islam into many other territories facilitated Arabian trade. Previously, that was complicated but new territories meant new consumers and clients. Muslims used the Arabic currency, the Dinar. Those were gold coins. There were also Dirham that was silver coins. With new territories and routes, Muslim merchants could trade spices, salt, sugar, textiles, and slaves, using the Silk Road.

The other options of the question were A) trade became the main work of the Arabian population. B) large numbers of people migrated to Arabia to engage in trade. D) Arabia established itself as the leading trade center of the world.

Which line from the English Bill of Rights describes one cause of James II’s removal from the throne

Answers

“By violating the freedom of election of members to serve in Parliament”

The line from the English Bill of Rights that describes one cause of James II's removal from the throne is: "By violating the freedom of election of members to serve in Parliament." The correct option is B.

This clause refers to James II's interference in the parliamentary election process, which undermined the democratic principles and rights of the people. By manipulating or suppressing the election of members of Parliament, James II infringed upon the constitutional rights and liberties of the English people.

The violation of this freedom was one of the factors that contributed to his removal from the throne and the subsequent ascension of William and Mary as monarchs.  

Thus, the ideal selection is option B.

Learn more about English Bill of Rights here:

https://brainly.com/question/13340273

#SPJ4

The complete question might be:

Which line from the English Bill of Rights describes one cause of James II’s removal from the throne?

A "And thereupon the said Lords . . . being now assembled in a full and free representative of this nation"

B "By violating the freedom of election of members to serve in Parliament"

C "And they do claim, demand, and insist upon all . . . their undoubted rights and liberties"

D "The said Lords . . . do resolve that William and Mary, prince and princess of Orange, be, and be declared, king and queen of England"

the American value of government by elected representatives to the people was first demonstrated by the

Answers

House of Burgesses in Jamestown. 

Answer: b

Explanation:

The Italian wars that began in 1494 helped spread Renaissance ideas to A)Portugal.
B)Spain.
C)England.
D)France.

Answers

Answer:

France.

Explanation:

no comment.

Italian wars that began in 1494 helped spread Renaissance ideas to Portugal. The appropriate response is option A.

What is the Italian wars in 1494?

Italian Wars, a string of bloody conflicts between 1494 and 1559 for control of Italy. The Spanish Habsburgs dominated Italy as a result of these wars, which were fought mostly by France and Spain but involved much of Europe. This shifted power from Italy to northwest Europe.

When Charles VIII of France was pushed to invade Italy using the Angevin claim to the throne of Naples as a justification, Ludovico Sforza, the Regent of Milan at the time, the start of the war.

The Italian Wars were over with the Cateau-Cambrésis pact. Their primary accomplishment was the creation of Spanish hegemony in Italy and the elevation of Spain to the position of Europe's dominant power.

Making paper, the printing press, and the founding of new colleges all contributed to the Renaissance's expansion outside of Italy and into other intellectually progressive nations. 

To learn more about Italian wars

https://brainly.com/question/239941

#SPJ6

In ______, slavery increased rapidly here due to expansion of plantation agriculture producing rice and indigo.

Answers

the answer to this question is Carolina
Carolina has the perfect climates that needed to produce good quality grains/crops such as rice and indigo.
Since it opened up a lot of production opportunity, the region also require a lot of labor forces to work in the plantations, which they mostly get from slaves.

List at least three characteristics of society before the Renaissance.

Answers

Age of recovery

Urban society

Individual abilities
Before the Renaissance, Europe was a feudal society with weak central governments. Religion was a major force in society. Art was created only for religious purposes, and books were copied by hand

what proved to be a major hardship for settlement in the new English colonies

Answers

Exporting Raw materials to England 
The first English emigrants to what would become the New England colonies arrived in Plymouth in 1620. They were called Pilgrims.Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New Hampshire, and Connecticut were one of the first New England Colonies .A major hardship for settlement in the new English colonies was exporting raw materials to England.

Read a draft sentence from an argumentative essay.

When Japanese Americans were relocated to internment camps, they lost many things.


Which is the best revision of this sentence to make it more specific?



a- When Japanese Americans were relocated to internment camps, they suffered many devastating losses.

b- When Japanese Americans were relocated to internment camps, they lost homes, farms, and belongings.

c- Relocating Japanese Americans to internment camps caused them to suffer many devastating losses.

d- Relocating Japanese Americans to internment camps caused them to lose many things.

Answers

If you look at the answers you will see that one of them is not like the rest. A says they suffered many devastating losses. C says they suffered many devastating losses. And D says they lost many things. They are all the same basically. But B states specific things they lost like homes farms and belongings. Therefore your answer would be B! I hope this helps! =)

The best revision of this sentence to make it more specific is B. When Japanese Americans were relocated to internment camps, they lost homes, farms, and belongings.

What makes a person Japanese American?

The era of human beings born in Japan who later immigrated to another USA. The technology of human beings born in North U.S, Latin America, Hawaii, or any united states of America outdoor Japan either to at the least one Issei or one non-immigrant eastern figure.

What percent of the united states is Japanese?

According to the American network Survey, a brand new national survey by means of the USA Census Bureau, 3.4% of the USA's overseas-born Asian population, or 343,746, were from Japan.

Learn more about Japanese American here https://brainly.com/question/805452

#SPJ2

What assumption did the new york times “ethicist" contest call into question?

Answers

The New York Times "ethicist" contest call into the question the assumption that it is natural and right to eat meat by asking people to write persuasive arguments in favor of eating meat.

The New York Times 'Ethicist' contest called into question the assumption that it is natural and right to eat meat. Thus, option (b) is correct.

The New York Times 'Ethicist' contest aimed to explore and challenge assumptions surrounding meat consumption.One of the main assumptions called into question is that eating meat is natural and, therefore, morally acceptable.The idea here is that the naturalness of an action does not necessarily justify its moral permissibility.The contest encouraged participants to consider whether common justifications for eating meat, such as tradition and naturalness, genuinely hold up under ethical scrutiny.Arguments also included examining the suffering caused to animals by meat consumption and whether there are healthier and more ethical alternatives.

Complete Question:

What assumption did the New York Times “Ethicist” contest call into question?

a. Eating meat causes suffering to animals.

b. It is natural and right to eat meat.

c. It is possible to avoid meat and still enjoy a healthy diet.

d. Meat-eaters don’t care about animal suffering.

Other Questions
How many minutes are there in a 40 hours week? I NEED HELP PLEASE. (I will give brainliest to the correct answer.)In a magazine advertisement, a manufacturer claims its laundry ball, which contains ceramic pellets, gets clothes clean by changing the pH of the water. The ad claims the product reduces wear on their clothing, contaminants in the environment, and the cost of doing laundry. What should the advertisement include to give a consumer more confidence in this product's claims?a. Information about product testing in a study that includes a control groupb. A lack of testimony from users who have used the product for several monthsc. Pictures comparing loads of laundry cleaned with and without the productd. Information about how the product benefits the environment Write two inequalities to compare -9 and -6 Question 9 solid sodium chloride is produced by the reaction of chlorine gas and solid sodium . write a balanced chemical equation for this reaction List and explain one-two themes that are presented in the last shot by darcy frey. Based on this stanza from a poem by Robert Frost, what is the poem's main idea? What is the surface area to volume ratio of this cube ( 5cm on all sides) How many pairs of whole numbers have a sum of 110 What is the cleaning method for frozen yogurt machines called? How does not knowing what fortunato did to montresor intendify the horror of in the cask of amontillado? A stimulation of senses results from various sources of energy such as light and sound and the presence of chemicals A pair of parallel lines is cut by a transversal:What is the measure of angle x? 60 degrees70 degrees80 degrees100 degrees If 2 grams of element X combines with 4 g of element y to form a compound XY, How many grams of element y would combine with 35 g of X to form the same compound three of the following methods were used by the roman republic to ensure the loyalty of conquered people in Italy. which was notA. Full roman citizenship was given to other LatinsB. Roman soldiers and farmers were settled in other parts of ItalyC.Mass evacuations of non-Latin were carried out by the roman armyD. Military roads were built between Rome and other Italian cities In all my years at Shawshank, there have been less than ten men whom I believed when they told me they were innocent. Andy Dufresne was one of them, although I only became convinced of his innocence over a period of years. If I had been on the jury that heard his case in Portland Superior Court over six stormy weeks in 1947-48, I would have voted to convinct, too.Source: King, Stephen. "Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption." Different Seasons. New York: Penguin Group, 1982. Google Books. Web. 16 May 2011.How does the point of view in the excerpt affect the characterization in the text? The japanese wanted to move first against the united states because _______. 5.Mr. Martin's Spanish class is 45 minutes long. If it starts at 3:30, what time does it end? In ipv4 addressing, each ip address is a unique ____ number. a. 12-bit b. 32-bit c. 64-bit d. 128-bit How do the shareholders of most corporations exercise their control of that corporation? Olivia is conducting training on the best way to enhance teamwork skills. which domain of learning does this represent? Steam Workshop Downloader